Blog > After a $12.2 Million Cut, a Fisher Island Penthouse Still Comes In Near the Record
After a $12.2 Million Cut, a Fisher Island Penthouse Still Comes In Near the Record
by
The Palazzo Della Luna residence sold for $37.8 million in October, the private island’s second-highest home sale ever — and a useful lesson in pricing realism.
By Julia Ray, Broker/Owner, Raydiant Realty, Hallandale Beach, FL (License BK3433857)
November 21, 2026
Luxury headlines often linger on the asking price. This sale is more useful because of the gap between the ask and the close.
A seven-bedroom penthouse at Palazzo Della Luna on Fisher Island sold on October 28, 2026, for $37.8 million. It had first come to market in June 2025 at $50 million. That is a $12.2 million reduction, or about 24%, from the original asking price. Even so, Realtor.com reports it as the island’s second-highest residential sale ever, behind a condominium that sold for $40 million in 2021.
The home helps explain why the number still landed so high. Built in 2019, the residence has 9,852 square feet of interior space, or $3,837 a square foot. Floor-to-ceiling windows and retractable glass walls open to about 4,500 square feet of terraces, with views of the Atlantic Ocean, Biscayne Bay and the Miami skyline. A 2,500-square-foot rooftop terrace has an outdoor kitchen and its own private pool. There are also staff quarters and garage parking for two cars. Sam Gaita of The Corcoran Group listed the property. In a recap of Miami-Dade’s top sales for the week ending November 1, RealtyWire confirmed the $37.8 million close at 6893 Fisher Island Drive. The penthouse had last sold for $23.75 million in 2021.
By last summer, The Real Deal reported that the asking price was already just under $40 million, much closer to the final number than that original $50 million ask.
What it means for South Florida luxury buyers and sellers
A 24% cut can sound like a retreat. In this case, it looks more like a reset that let a rare property actually trade — and still close within reach of the island’s record. The first price is a theory. The sold price is the market.
For sellers, especially at the high end, the lesson is not that luxury demand has vanished. It is that serious buyers will pay a remarkable number for the right home, but they will also wait out an ask that feels disconnected from recent sales. For buyers, a large reduction is not automatically a bargain, and a near-record close is not proof that every asking price was fair. It is a signal to study the property, the price history and the comparable sales, then decide based on today’s evidence.
We’re here if you need a steady hand
If you are buying or selling in South Florida’s luxury market, or trying to read what a headline sale means for your own pricing, please reach out to me at Raydiant Realty. I can help you put sales like this in context and keep your next move on solid ground.
This post is for general information only and is not legal, insurance or tax advice. Confirm details with the appropriate professional and with the linked sources.
Julia Ray
Broker/Owner, Raydiant Realty
Hallandale Beach, Florida
License BK3433857

